$50 Int'l Calling Credit (Costco Purchase) = SNEAKY FRAUD!!

Something on your mind? Want to give us feedback on something in particular or everything in general? Tell us how we are doing!
oomg
Posts: 593
Joined: Fri Feb 20, 2009 3:59 am
Location: SoCal -- L.A.

Re: $50 Int'l Calling Credit (Costco Purchase) = SNEAKY FRAUD!!

Post by oomg » Thu Aug 20, 2009 10:09 am

jm9496 wrote:unfortunatly ORC § 1349.61 is

(1) the value prepaid for international service falls under "electronic card, or other medium" as defined under Ohio law. It is a credit sorted in a medium exchangeable for services.

(2) it is not excluded as a calling card. There is no access number, access codes, or other key features that define the trademark components of calling cards other than the affiliation with a telephone company, nor is it called a "calling card used to make phone calls". It is called international credit. "credit" clarifies that this is analogous a store credit.

(3) while costco is unknowingly guilty of (A)(1), Ooma, Inc. is guilty of (A)(2) and liable.

(4) because money was exchanged for the device and credit (i.e it was purchased), it is not meet the definition of promotional program as excepted under (C)(2). (promotional programs are giveaways, like free burrito coupons chipolte gives away every once in a while)

(4.1) Note that this was purchased as a package. Ohio laws regulating the selling of items together, use of the word "free," etc. are collectively referred to as "the Ohio consumer fair sales practices act."
Unless you have case law to support you interpretation, you are only providing your interpretation. Likewise, I have only provided my interpretation. And, I'm sure we respectfully disagree. However, I am open to review any published opinion on the topic and may reconsider accordingly.
oomg -- Voice Over Internet Person

I've learned a lot here... two months ago I didn't even know how to spell VOIP and now I are one.

mcbleu
Posts: 39
Joined: Tue Aug 11, 2009 11:01 am

Re: $50 Int'l Calling Credit (Costco Purchase) = SNEAKY FRAUD!!

Post by mcbleu » Fri Aug 21, 2009 10:48 pm

in California , calling card have to have the expiration date (if any) clearly marked at the purchasing time.
"" Disclose all fees, add-ons, and surcharges in a clear and conspicuous manner....""
""...California's false advertising and unfair competition laws....""

I'm in california and the $50 International Calling Credit
shouldn't expire if they do;
contact ( and I will ) contact costco directly as they are the one giving the
$50 International Calling Credit.

The $50 International Calling Credit is the reason I bought ooma from costco and not another retailer

P.S. I'm so happy with ooma service that I don't care that much about the $50

sclin
Posts: 4
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 3:46 pm

Re: $50 Int'l Calling Credit (Costco Purchase) = SNEAKY FRAUD!!

Post by sclin » Sat Aug 22, 2009 5:18 pm

Ooma asked me to contact Costco, since it's their promotion they told me that they have nothing to do with it.

I contacted Costco and they refer the $50 credit back to Ooma, since they don't even know the expriation date and they have no control over how Ooma does their business. Costco have no problem giving my money back if I am not happy with it.

Both Ooma and Costco does not offer any help to reslove this issue. The buttom line is that both Ooma and Costco mislead customer and does not care even cusotmer complain period!

oomg
Posts: 593
Joined: Fri Feb 20, 2009 3:59 am
Location: SoCal -- L.A.

Re: $50 Int'l Calling Credit (Costco Purchase) = SNEAKY FRAUD!!

Post by oomg » Sun Aug 23, 2009 7:53 am

mcbleu wrote:in California , calling card have to have the expiration date (if any) clearly marked at the purchasing time.
"" Disclose all fees, add-ons, and surcharges in a clear and conspicuous manner....""
""...California's false advertising and unfair competition laws....""

I'm in california and the $50 International Calling Credit
shouldn't expire if they do;
contact ( and I will ) contact costco directly as they are the one giving the
$50 International Calling Credit.

The $50 International Calling Credit is the reason I bought ooma from costco and not another retailer

P.S. I'm so happy with ooma service that I don't care that much about the $50
For a good overview of California law, go to:
http://www.cpuc.ca.gov/PUC/aboutus/Divi ... ecards.htm

Once again, the definition of a prepaid calling card would appear to exclude the Costco promotion since the international credit is not being sold separately, but rather included as a promotional item.
oomg -- Voice Over Internet Person

I've learned a lot here... two months ago I didn't even know how to spell VOIP and now I are one.

mikepa
Posts: 17
Joined: Mon Aug 24, 2009 1:52 pm

Re: $50 Int'l Calling Credit (Costco Purchase) = SNEAKY FRAUD!!

Post by mikepa » Mon Aug 24, 2009 2:02 pm

I too was surprised to find the promised $50 credit expires after 90 days and am surprised Costo hasn't either taken Ooma to task or clarified the position on their web site.

Unless Ooma rectifies this before my minutes expire, my unit goes back to Costo and I either look for a cheaper Ooma unit (Hub only) elsewhere or I change to a service like Phone Power which offers similar capabilities albeit not for a one time purchase price like Ooma.

BTW, OOma's service isn't that good! After only a week my power supply blew. Ooma suggested I buy a new one at Home Depot! (Radio Shack maybe?) at my expense or they could send me a new one but it would take two weeks to arrive. When I asked if replacing a defective hub would take as long the agent said "yes". I did speak to a customer service director later who assured me it would not take that long to replace a bub.

jm9496
Posts: 97
Joined: Mon Jul 20, 2009 5:45 pm

Re: $50 Int'l Calling Credit (Costco Purchase) = SNEAKY FRAUD!!

Post by jm9496 » Tue Aug 25, 2009 8:16 am

sclin wrote:Ooma asked me to contact Costco, since it's their promotion they told me that they have nothing to do with it.
...
Both Ooma and Costco does not offer any help to reslove this issue.
This is all just finger pointing until this issue ends up in court.

oomg
Posts: 593
Joined: Fri Feb 20, 2009 3:59 am
Location: SoCal -- L.A.

Re: $50 Int'l Calling Credit (Costco Purchase) = SNEAKY FRAUD!!

Post by oomg » Tue Aug 25, 2009 8:36 am

jm9496 wrote:
sclin wrote:Ooma asked me to contact Costco, since it's their promotion they told me that they have nothing to do with it.
...
Both Ooma and Costco does not offer any help to reslove this issue.
This is all just finger pointing until this issue ends up in court.
...and it is unlikely to have a binding authority until such time as an appellate court renders its opinion regarding the applicability of the statute. Don't forget, it is possible that different courts could render a different decision, even if the respective state law is similar or the same.
oomg -- Voice Over Internet Person

I've learned a lot here... two months ago I didn't even know how to spell VOIP and now I are one.

niknak
Posts: 885
Joined: Tue Jan 27, 2009 7:53 pm
Location: Staten Island, NY

Re: $50 Int'l Calling Credit (Costco Purchase) = SNEAKY FRAUD!!

Post by niknak » Tue Aug 25, 2009 11:15 am

...This is all just finger pointing until this issue ends up in court...
I doubt a 50$ squabble will end up in court

mikepa
Posts: 17
Joined: Mon Aug 24, 2009 1:52 pm

Re: $50 Int'l Calling Credit (Costco Purchase) = SNEAKY FRAUD!!

Post by mikepa » Tue Aug 25, 2009 12:54 pm

For all the bad will this is generating, I can't believe Ooma just doesn't say OK, we'll give people a year to use the credit. I believe even in a year many people will still not use the credit so it's not like the move would cost Ooma megabucks. To do nothing will cost them in returned hubs. Mine for one.

The fact stands now that to many places where Americans would call they would have to spend 30 minutes a day on international calls just to use up the $50 which is clearly stupid.

oomg
Posts: 593
Joined: Fri Feb 20, 2009 3:59 am
Location: SoCal -- L.A.

Re: $50 Int'l Calling Credit (Costco Purchase) = SNEAKY FRAUD!!

Post by oomg » Wed Aug 26, 2009 8:39 am

niknak wrote:
...This is all just finger pointing until this issue ends up in court...
I doubt a 50$ squabble will end up in court
This is the sort of thing that would generally be handled as a "class-action" suit. Attorneys bring suit... target agrees to change their policy... proposed settlement agreement which usually must be approved by court, provides for payment of attorney's fees and some token compensation to members of the class (e.g. a coupon that entitles airline travel at some nominal discount; or a coupon for $50 international calling credit which expires in 90 days). Quite often the
compensation to the individual consumer is meaningless.
oomg -- Voice Over Internet Person

I've learned a lot here... two months ago I didn't even know how to spell VOIP and now I are one.

Locked